« Gas fireplace wont light? | Home | Outdoor fireplace design? »
Chiminea vs Fire pit - what’s best?
By admin | October 29, 2007
cavapasmieux asked:
I'm thinking of buying a chiminea or fire pit (Gas patio heater out of question as not eco-friendly), it will be placed on the decking and I need to think about safety aspect with 2 young children.
Any recommendations?
![]() NEW PAGODA PATIO FIREPLACE RECTANGLE FIRE PIT BACKYARD US $196.11
|
![]() 30 STAINLESS STEEL FIRE PIT BACKYARD FIREPLACE HEATER US $145.82
|
![]() NEW RECTANGLE PAGODA PATIO FIREPLACE FIRE PIT BACKYARD US $196.11
|
5 Responses to “Chiminea vs Fire pit - what’s best?”




US $196.11



October 30th, 2003 at 9:47 pm
I like the chiminea myself. Out camping I like a fire pit.
November 1st, 2003 at 9:41 am
dangerous to touch - safety screen needed where there are children
Place some slates under the legs - these are fireproof
November 4th, 2003 at 9:28 pm
I’d go for a chiminea, but you need to re-think your “eco-ideas”. How is burning long-dead trees, (gas), better than burning fresh trees, (charcoal or wood)? As long as you re-plant new trees, you can be carbon-neutral either way.
November 6th, 2003 at 7:52 pm
I myself have a Chiminea which is excellent, if you do get one you must remember that they can be dangerous, put a 3ftx2ft slab on your decking before hand to save any burning, remember to keep children away from it. Fire pit is a different story all together with a Chiminea it is partly enclosed,a fire pit is more open so in any wind(especially on wooden decking) it can become very dangerous. not forgetting anyone falling into it after a drink or two. I think you should go for a good old Chiminea.
The clay ones have a lot shorter lifespan than cast iron.
Have fun.
Professional Gardner for 30 odd yrs
November 7th, 2003 at 9:10 am
A traditional chiminea design is easier to light and more efficient to burn because of proper drafting. Compared to a fire pit, a chiminea is much more enjoyable and you will use it a lot more often then a fire pit because it can be used in breezy situations where a fire pit will not be safe. Clay falls apart and cast iron rusts, so get a good cast aluminum one and it will last for many years. See The Blue Rooster Companies “10 Free Tips to Buying an Outdoor Fireplace” and the “FAQ” section for more information on chimineas and fire pits.